If you liked Body in the Water…

These picks come from archytele's own similarity graph: shared themes and keywords, creators, cast, era, original language and audience rating. Each card says why it made the list.

★ 10.0

Killer Grannies

2025

Both explore true crime; both crime and documentary

★ 9.0

Murder Case: The Digital Detectives

2024

Both explore true crime; both crime and documentary

★ 7.4

Cabin in the Woods

2024

Both explore true crime; both crime and documentary

★ 8.4

A Killer Among Friends

2025

Both explore true crime; both crime and documentary

★ 8.0

Texas True Crime

2021

Both explore true crime; both crime and documentary

★ 9.0

911: Did the Killer Call?

2025

Both explore true crime; both crime and documentary

★ 7.3

The Predator of Seville

2026

Both explore true crime; both crime and documentary

★ 7.0

Forensics: Catching the Killer

2021

Both explore crime scene and true crime; both crime and documentary

★ 8.3

Crime in Progress

2026

Both explore true crime; both crime and documentary

★ 8.7

Vow of Silence: The Assassination of Annie Mae

2024

Both explore true crime; both crime and documentary

★ 8.6

Married to Evil

2023

Both explore true crime; both crime and documentary

★ 7.5

Welcome to the Family: The Murder of Dan Markel

2026

Both explore true crime; both crime and documentary