If you liked The Wrong Babysitter…

These picks come from archytele's own similarity graph: shared themes and keywords, creators, cast, era, original language and audience rating. Each card says why it made the list.

★ 5.8 Film

Long Lost Daughter

2018

Both explore kidnapping and held hostage; both tv movie and thriller

★ 5.0 Film

Nightmare Tenant

2018

Both explore murder and murdered; both tv movie and thriller

★ 4.9 Film

Secrets of My Stepdaughter

2017

Both explore murder; both tv movie and thriller

★ 5.8 Film

Mommy's Little Boy

2017

Both explore held hostage; both tv movie and thriller

★ 6.0 Film

Her Boyfriend's Secret

2018

Both explore killing and murder; both tv movie and thriller

★ 7.4 Film

Escaping the Madhouse: The Nellie Bly Story

2019

Both explore murder; both tv movie and thriller

★ 5.8 Film

A Daughter's Revenge

2018

Both explore killing and murder; both tv movie

★ 5.7 Film

Mommy I Didn't Do It

2017

Both explore murder; both tv movie and thriller

★ 5.1 Film

Murder at the Lighthouse

2025

Both explore murder; both tv movie and thriller

★ 6.1 Film

Deadly Cheer Mom

2022

Both explore killing and murder; both tv movie and thriller

★ 4.6 Film

The Kidnapping of the President

1980

Same creator (George Mendeluk); both explore kidnapping

★ 5.4 Film

Caught

2015

Both explore kidnapping; both tv movie and thriller