If you liked The Mothman Prophecies…

These picks come from archytele's own similarity graph: shared themes and keywords, creators, cast, era, original language and audience rating. Each card says why it made the list.

★ 7.5 Film

The Devil's Advocate

1997

Both explore hallucination; both drama and horror

★ 6.2 Film

They Look Like People

2016

Both explore paranoia and hallucination; both drama and horror

★ 7.0 Film

Arlington Road

1999

Same creator (Mark Pellington); both explore paranoia

★ 6.4 Film

The Nightmare

2015

Both explore hospital; both drama and horror

★ 7.4 Film

Jacob's Ladder

1990

Both explore paranoia and hallucination; both drama and horror

★ 6.5 Film

The Gift

2000

Both explore small town and dreams; both drama and horror

★ 7.4 Film

Twin Peaks: Fire Walk with Me

1992

Both explore small town; both drama and horror

★ 6.0 Film

Butterfly Kisses

2018

Both explore urban legend; both drama and horror

★ 6.3 Film

Final Destination 2

2003

Both explore premonition and hospital; both horror and mystery

★ 5.8 Film

Handling the Undead

2024

Both explore based on novel or book and grief; both drama and horror

★ 6.4 Film

Mr. Harrigan's Phone

2022

Both explore small town and grief; both drama and horror

★ 5.8 Film

One Point O

2004

Both explore paranoia; both drama and horror