★ 6.7
Lunar Legend Tsukihime
2003
Both explore immortality and supernatural; both animation and mystery
★ 6.6
The Mystic Archives of Dantalian
2011
Both explore detective and supernatural; both animation and mystery
★ 6.6
Dance in the Vampire Bund
2010
Both explore supernatural and gore; both animation and drama
★ 8.3
Elfen Lied
2004
Both explore supernatural and gore; both animation and mystery
★ 7.9
Supernatural: The Anime Series
2011
Both explore supernatural and anime; both animation and mystery
★ 6.7
Freezing
2011
Both explore seinen and ecchi; both animation and drama