What to watch after I Am Not a Serial Killer

These picks come from archytele's own similarity graph: shared themes and keywords, creators, cast, era, original language and audience rating. Each card says why it made the list.

★ 6.2 Film

Scream 7

2026

Both explore murder and serial killer; both horror and mystery

★ 6.5 Film

Longlegs

2024

Both explore murder and serial killer; both horror and mystery

★ 6.7 Film

Psycho Killer

2026

Both explore murder and serial killer; both horror and mystery

★ 5.3 Film

Nine Dead

2010

Both explore murder; both horror and mystery

★ 5.2 Film

Pig Killer

2022

Both explore serial killer; both horror and mystery

★ 6.7 Film

Strange Harvest

2025

Both explore serial killer; both horror and mystery

★ 5.2 Film

The Snowman

2017

Both explore based on novel or book and winter; both horror and mystery

★ 6.1 Film

Resurrection

1999

Both explore psychopath and gore; both horror and mystery

★ 6.3 Film

The Ritual

2017

Both explore based on novel or book and murder; both horror and mystery

★ 6.8 Film

The Pale Blue Eye

2022

Both explore based on novel or book and winter; both horror and mystery

★ 6.8 Film

The Autopsy of Jane Doe

2016

Both explore supernatural and murder; both horror and mystery

★ 6.6 Film

It Follows

2015

Both explore supernatural; both horror and mystery