What to watch after Fantasy Island

These picks come from archytele's own similarity graph: shared themes and keywords, creators, cast, era, original language and audience rating. Each card says why it made the list.

★ 6.0 Film

Gretel & Hansel

2020

Both explore dark fantasy; shared fantasy / horror DNA

★ 6.4 Film

The Watchers

2024

Both explore dark fantasy; shared fantasy / horror DNA

★ 6.3 Film

A Dark Song

2016

Both explore supernatural; shared fantasy / horror DNA

★ 5.3 Film

Village of the Dead

2025

Both explore supernatural; shared adventure / horror DNA

★ 7.5 Film

Pinocchio: Unstrung

2026

Both explore dark fantasy; shared fantasy / horror DNA

★ 6.4 Film

Come Play

2020

Both explore supernatural and supernatural horror; shared horror / mystery DNA

★ 6.1 Film

Paranormal Activity: Next of Kin

2021

Both explore supernatural and supernatural horror; shared horror / mystery DNA

★ 7.1 Film

Children of the Sea

2019

Both explore supernatural; shared adventure / fantasy DNA

★ 6.1 Film

The Empty Man

2020

Both explore cave; shared horror / mystery DNA

★ 5.5 Film

The Mummy

2017

Both explore supernatural; shared adventure / fantasy DNA

★ 6.5 Film

The Cellar

2022

Both explore supernatural and supernatural horror; shared horror / mystery DNA

★ 6.2 Film

undertone

2026

Both explore supernatural and supernatural horror; shared horror / mystery DNA